Nobody can live on British overseas territory the Chagos Islands, at least for now

For decades British overseas territory the Chagos Islands have remained uninhabited apart from one of the islands Diego Garcia which is used as a UK-US military base.

Now the Court of Appeal and the British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT) Court of Appeal in London confirm that the outer islands that were last inhabited by Chagossian settlers and workers in the 1970s are off limits too.

British Chagossian campaigners Bertrice Pompe, from Indigenous Chagossian People (ICP) campaign group, along with Misley Mandarin brought a case heard at the Court of Appeal at the High Court this month, supported by the Great British PAC and others.

On Conservative Post, the GB PAC reported the bad news. The Chagossian claimants had lost their case. Lady Justice Andrews “dismissed applications brought by Chagossian claimants seeking to challenge the Government’s failure to reconsider their rights to return to the islands before any transfer of sovereignty to Mauritius” despite the judgement referring to the “long and shameful history to the treatment of the inhabitants of the Chagos Islands”.

Crucially the court said there was no legal obligation by Government to restore the right of abode simply because circumstances – acknowledged in the Chagos Islands treaty negotiations between the UK and Mauritian governments - may have changed.

Earlier in the month Misley Mandarin, Interim First Minister elected by BIOT Citizen campaign group, lost his case against the British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT) authorities in the BIOT Court of Appeal. The case was about the right of Chagossians to live back on the islands. He lost the case on a technicality: the BIOT Court cannot overturn British Government Royal Prerogative powers denying a right to abode, only English Courts can, it was ruled.

Last February BIOT authorities sent removal notices to six Chagossian men including Mandarin currently living on one of the islands the Ile de Coin. Despite losing a case in the BIOT Court of Appeal after the government successfully challenged their right to have a Judicial Review, lawyers for Mandarin may take the legal fight to the Privy Council.

While the Government’s sovereignty treaty with Mauritius is signed, it is not ratified after President Trump opposed the deal. So will law or politics win in the fight between the Government using executive powers and British citizens who are challenging it?

Perhaps politics will become the only forum in which Chagossians can win their rights to resettle on their ancestral homeland. If so will the British people become more widely opposed to a change of sovereignty of British overseas territory without their direct say so, now the Government is also thinking of ignoring British voters 2016 Referendum vote decision to take back control of sovereign powers from the European Union?

Tessa Clarke, Editor, THE CHAGOS FILES, 20 NOV.2026

THE CHAGOS FILES’ work aims to bring to light the undemocratic aspects of the Chagos Islands sovereignty issue, what it means for Chagossian people and all of us. Please support us financially to continue this work by clicking SUPPORT. Thank you.

THE CHAGOS FILES team

_______________________________________________

FOLLOW debates with

Tessa Clarke, Editor, THE CHAGOS FILES

on X at @tessaclarkelive

Next
Next

Is the Chagos Islands sovereignty deal dead? by Tessa Clarke,editor, THE CHAGOS FILES